
A Conversation with Robert Horster
Good morning, Robert, and welcome back to Commodity Conversations. First, could you tell me a bit about yourself?
I’m a Senior Fellow at the Erasmus Commodity and Trade Centre, where I teach, write, and advise clients; my writing is academic research. I spent 31 years at Cargill, and I want to share what I learned. In simple terms, my mission is to make people aware that they should not take food for granted.
I want to discuss who holds power in the food chain and how that has changed over the years, from landowners and slave owners to merchants, food processors, large food companies, and retailers. My thesis is that consumers now have power through social media, and that their votes can shape government policy. Do you agree that consumers now have power in the food chain?
It depends on how you define power. You are talking more about influence than power. You should focus more on asymmetries and dependencies. You could discuss purchasing power and who can move markets. Some countries and organisations can still move markets. There’s a strong geopolitical dimension, with government intervention and, perhaps more importantly, China’s rise.
Food can be weaponised. Who controls the choke points in the physical flows, or the data that underpins the food system? You are right that politicians have the power, but I don’t think they understand the food system, its dependencies and asymmetries. It is quite worrying.
I think many people underestimate China’s role in the food system. They view China as a threat in the same way that China is selling electric cars into Europe and threatening 50,000 jobs at Volkswagen. However, China has enabled us to enter an energy transition that, without its technology and knowledge, solar panels and EVs would not have been possible.
China is a super important power in the world of food, but also a power for good. Instead of framing the debate in terms of risk, we should ask: what can we do with China?
You mention China and the power it exerts through its enormous import flows. I recently read that China’s Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs has set a target to reduce soybean imports to 82.55 million tonnes by 2035, down from the record 111.83 million tonnes in 2025. Do you think they will succeed? If they do, it will have major repercussions for Brazilian and US farmers.
In round numbers, China produces about 20 million tonnes and imports 110 million tonnes of soybeans. Of its domestic production, about half goes to direct human consumption, such as tofu and similar products.
China is deeply concerned about its reliance on imports and is investing heavily in food technology and meat alternatives. I think it is also investing heavily in soybean genetics to increase protein content. Also, remember that the Chinese population is already falling, but that doesn’t necessarily mean we’ve seen peak meat demand.
So, a short answer is that China can reduce soybean imports, but not to the extent that NDRC would want to. Nowhere near, in fact. Meat consumption continues to grow as disposable incomes rise. Meat replacement, higher protein efficiency in food and, of course, more direct consumption of protein (legumes, peas, lentils, tofu) are more effective. Hence the focus on food technology in its 15th Five-Year Plan.
China has historically had considerable success with stock management, building stocks when prices were low and destocking when prices rose. Is that something other countries should try to imitate?
Yes, they should, but as part of a portfolio of interventions
In China, you have the State Council, and then you’ve got SOEs (state-owned enterprises) reporting directly to the government; to be precise, to the State-Owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission (SASAC). Managing food stocks has always been government policy, dating back to the iron-rice-bowl period. Remember that 15 to 20 per cent of the Chinese population still alive have lived through the famine that followed the Great Leap Forward. The government bears the costs of the policy, if any, and owns all the data.
There’s a move in England to build strategic grain stocks now. Is it a good idea?
We’re better off following other stockpiling examples. For example, after the 2008-9 rice crisis, Asian countries built decentralised rice stocks and promised to help each other by swapping and sharing inventories in times of need.
Stockpiling could be part of a food security solution, but it must be paired with diversified trade and domestic production. Solutions include redesigning what you grow domestically.
In an average US supermarket, there are about 30,000 different products. Are we talking about securing a supply line for all of them? Where do we draw the line? How do we decide what’s strategically important and what isn’t?
Switzerland already maintains strategic, mandatory emergency food and basic goods such as wheat, sugar, vegetable oils, coffee, and rice to cover 3-4 months of domestic demand.
The country does not store these goods in vast state-owned warehouses. Instead, the system relies on a public-private partnership. Importers, producers, and processors of vital goods must maintain mandatory reserves. Roughly 280 to 300 private companies own, store, regularly rotate, and manage the quality of these goods.
The smart thing that the government does is to let the private sector manage the stocks.
What do you recommend governments do?
The approach we’ve recommended in our report for the Netherlands is to base it on the number of calories. Make sure you reach that calorie target by optimising between the three nutrients: fats and oils, carbohydrates, and protein.
I would not recommend keeping stock of 30,000 goods; it’s unfeasible. Besides, what we eat is not necessarily what we need.
But isn’t focusing on calories the wrong thing to do, because you need to focus on healthy food, and healthy food doesn’t necessarily mean just calories?
We wrote our report in the context of disasters. In normal circumstances, when you have time to adjust, you don’t rely on calories. In a disaster, you do. We went through three scenarios. Flooding of half of the Netherlands, which, as you can imagine, could easily happen, since most of the country is below sea level. An actual kinetic conflict, as they call it. War, in other words. Or a massive cyberattack or IT failure. And there was a third one, which was geopolitical.
If you have the time to prepare, you don’t go by calories. You look at, to your point, what’s healthy? What does a healthy diet look like?
You should consider what we can produce ourselves. Vegetable protein, for instance, is much healthier than animal protein for several reasons, and it’s more sustainable because it produces fewer emissions. You usually need less land, and it’s also arguably cheaper because you use fewer resources.
We’re talking about food security. We’ve mentioned the Netherlands, Switzerland, the UK, and China, but what about the rest of the world who are currently food insecure? (1) Can we make food more secure for them?
We could, but it’s a global problem. To address it, we need to start thinking about big macro interventions.
Waste is a major issue, from the farm gate to the first point of collection and beyond. There’s a massive amount of waste: roughly half occurs in the first mile. A lot of ready food gets wasted at the kitchen table. So that would immediately free up a lot more food for the global population.
The market has many imperfections around mandated crop use for fuel. If you eliminated those mandates, you would free up food.
You’re still left with the distribution problem. If there’s a crisis and someone bans exports, it escalates.
Food security is not just about food; it’s about fertilisers, herbicides, pesticides, and, most importantly, diesel. The disruptions are coming from everywhere.
Geopolitical conflicts and trade wars are laying bare how vulnerable the food system is. As Warren Buffett says, when the tide goes out, you can see who’s swimming naked.
Coming back to the report we did for the Dutch government, we looked at the supply chain- the grain traders, the processors and all the way down to the supermarkets- and came to the conclusion that we have eleven days of food in the system in the Netherlands.
And that’s because of the way our food system is designed. Nobody decided to do it this way, but it’s because of what we consume, as you mentioned earlier, and because agriculture has evolved into big-scale, high-efficiency, low-cost agriculture.
So, is the food system broken?
I don’t think the food system is broken, but it needs to be redesigned.
We must distinguish here between food security and security of supply. For example, security of supply was jeopardised when Russia invaded Ukraine. I’m not sure what the situation was in Switzerland, but we had no sunflower oil. The shelves were empty here for days on end.
With security of supply, you’ve got some optionality in the system. If there is no sunflower oil from Ukraine, then we can use rapeseed oil from Germany. If there are no soybeans from Brazil, then we import from the US. So the system isn’t broken, but it needs some repair. However, what really needs repair is the food security equation.
Food security is more about economic access. Is enough food available for all of us, wherever we are, to lead a healthy life, and is the food nutritious? I think the system for delivering healthy food at a reasonable price is broken, to use your terms. It needs repair.
Are we moving fast enough from just-in-time to just-in-case? Or are we hoping the problem goes away?
I think people are hoping it goes away.
Food security is on the agenda right now. That’s probably also why we’re having our conversation. Every time you speak to politicians, lawmakers, or even people in our ecosystem, food has become a topic. Food is never a topic of conversation until it’s not there.
We’re moving to a system of just in case. But the major reaction is stockpiling. And stockpiling is not the only solution. Other solutions include redesigning what you grow domestically.
We have time to prepare. I hope we don’t postpone this until the proverbial shit hits the fan and then make decisions. We’ve got a whole portfolio of things we can do now that we have the time.
Thank you, Robert, for taking the time to speak with us.
- According to the definitive global benchmark, the UN State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World (SOFI) Report, an estimated 2.1 billion people—roughly 25.8% of the global population—suffer from moderate or severe food insecurity. They lack regular access to sufficient, safe, and nutritious food, forcing them to routinely compromise on the quality or overall quantity of what they eat.
Out of the broader 2.1 billion, 645 million, or roughly 7.8% of the world’s population, experience severe hunger. These individuals have run out of food, experienced hunger, and, at worst, gone entire days without eating.
©CommodityConversations®2026
I have updated my first book, The Sugar Casino, and it is now available on Amazon

















